When Does a Cyber Attack Justify Use of Force?

https://www.freepik.com/free-vector/colored-hacker-code-realistic-composition-with-person-creates-codes-hacking-stealing-information-vector-illustration_4300282.htm
https://www.freepik.com/free-vector/colored-hacker-code-realistic-composition-with-person-creates-codes-hacking-stealing-information-vector-illustration_4300282.htm

I. Introduction and Background

Imagine a scenario: during winter, a nation’s power grid suddenly goes down, urban centers lose heating, and the nation’s hospitals lose power, resulting in the death of patients. After an investigation, the source of the power outage is identified to be a cyber intrusion by a foreign state. No conventional combat occurred, yet the consequences resemble those of a conventional military strike. Scenarios like this are no longer speculative situations, they are real world risks as foreign states at large possess the ability to launch devastating cyber-attacks.[1] What recourse is there for this fictional nation? Does this “attack” give the nation a right to use force as a countermeasure?[2]

Article 2(4) of the United Nations Charter establishes a foundational prohibition against the threat or use of force.[3] Exceptions to this provision allow the use of force in self-defense if an armed attack occurs.[4] Article 2(4) was drafted in response to kinetic violence that reflected the brutalities of the second world war; to the drafters of this article, force meant tanks, bombs, and bullets.[5] Cyber operations, by contrast, operate through code, networks, and infrastructure dependencies that the Charter’s drafters could not have anticipated.[6]

This resulted in an interpretive gap; despite not being considered conventional warfare, cyber-attacks have the capability to produce severe harm including damage and injury.[7] They can disrupt essential services, degrade digital infrastructure, and in many cases cause injury or death.[8] The question is, when does a cyber operation cross the legal threshold from unlawful interference into an “armed attack” that triggers the right of self-defense under the U.N. Charter?[9] Most cyber operations violate sovereignty or interfere with domestic affairs, but only a small subset amount to an ‘armed attack.’[10] The best approach is an effect-based framework that evaluates scale and consequences rather than method of delivery.[11]

II. Legal Thresholds Debated in International Law

There are several categories of cyber intrusions that states deal with on a daily basis that do not rise to the threshold of use of force, and armed attack.[12] Per the Tallin Manual, a persuasive but not binding international legal treatise on cyber warfare, “the term ‘armed attack’ is not to be equated with the term ‘use of force . . .’ and “an armed attack presupposes at least a use of force in the sense of Article 2(4) . . . not every use of force rises to the level of an armed attack.”[13] Cyber intrusions that cause mere inconvenience or irritation, non-destructive influence/psychological operations are not considered to be intrusions that rise to a use of force or armed attack.[14] Additionally, espionage, theft, and non-essential service interruptions are generally understood to fall below the threshold of a use of force or armed attack, furthermore, there are several cyber intrusions that are considered a use of force but not an armed attack.[15] Some cyber operations can be considered a use of force but still fall short of armed attack.[16]

The Tallinn manual also provides guidance on cyber operations that do rise to the level of an armed attack and therefore permits the state to respond in self-defense.[17] Intrusions that result in serious injuries and death of people and cause significant damage comparable to a kinetic strike rise to the level of an armed attack.[18] The manual also states that responses to situations where cyber incursions cause extensive negative effects and not injury, death, and damage is unsettled.[19]

III. Approaches to Determine Thresholds

Under international humanitarian law (IHL) there are two approaches to determine if a cyber incursion is an armed attack: an effects-based approach and an instrument-based approach.[20] The effects-based approach asks the question: “can an operation that does not produce physical effects similar to those of a kinetic weapon be an attack?”[21] By asking this question, states can evaluate whether the cyber intrusion results in loss of life or destroying critical infrastructure as a kinetic attack would.[22] This approach aligns with the underlying purpose of the U.N. Charter by prioritizing the scale and severity of harm rather than the means by which it is inflicted, thereby preventing states from evading legal accountability simply because force is delivered through digital rather than physical means.[23] The instrument-based approach to cyber incursions classifies an incursion based on the means or methods used rather than the effect of what the incursion produced.[24] Under this approach the cyber operation may qualify as a use of force or even an armed attack if the cyber method functions like a conventional weapon.[25] The question for the instrument-based approach is could the cyber tool used in the operation be qualified as a weapon? [26]

IV. Conclusion

Cyber operations challenge traditional assumptions about force, violence, and attack. But the underlying principles of the Charter remain durable. The prohibition on force and the right of self-defense are not artifacts of weapon type; they are functions of harm, scale, and necessity.

As cyber capabilities expand, state practice will continue shaping the contours of these rules. The central task for international law is not to reinvent doctrine, but to apply existing principles coherently to new technologies, ensuring that neither escalation nor impunity defines the digital battlefield. The best approach is an effect-based framework that evaluates scale and consequences rather than method of delivery.


[1] U.S. Dep’t of Homeland Sec., 2025 Homeland Threat Assessment (2025), pg. 21.

[2] U.N. Charter art. 51.

[3] U.N. Charter art. 2, para. 4.

[4] Supra note 2.

[5] See Bruno Simma et al., The Charter of the United Nations: A Commentary 135, 145 (3d ed. 2012).

[6] Braden A. Smith, Force by Other Means: Developing a Comprehensive Method for Identifying Transnational Cyber Attacks as Article 2(4) Violations, 105 Cal. L. Rev.

[7] Tallinn Manual 2.0 on the International Law Applicable to Cyber Operations r. 92, at 126 (Michael N. Schmitt ed., 2d ed. 2017) [hereinafter Tallinn Manual 2.0].

[8] Id. at 38.

[9] Id. at 125.

[10] Id. at 11.

[11] Id. at 330.

[12] Schmitt et al., supra note 7, at 1.

[13] Id.

[14] Id. at 37.

[15] Id. at 341.

[16] Id.

[17] Id.

[18] Id.

[19] Id. at 342.

[20] Orr, Z. (2024, May 14). Cyber attack war crimes and Ntaganda. Lieber Institute West Point. Retrieved from https://lieber.westpoint.edu/cyber-attack-war-crimes-ntaganda/

[21] Id.

[22] Id.

[23] Schmitt et al., supra note 7, at 1.

[24] Orr. Z., supra note 20.

[25] Id.

[26] Id.