In an increasingly interconnected global economy, international legal disputes are inevitable.[1] Naturally, a robust and reliable mechanism must exist to resolve these legal conflicts. While courtroom litigation is certainly an effective means to do so, there are other alternative dispute resolution systems, including international arbitration, that stand on equal footing.
Arbitration is a private process[2] where parties resolve their dispute before a selected panel of arbitrators. The United States has long recognized international arbitration as a legitimate means to resolve conflicts, as reflected in the number of conflict resolution treaties signed in the early twentieth century.[3] Between 1909 and 1932, the U.S. enacted thirty-two international arbitration treaties.[4] At the time, more international businesses and government agencies were contracting with each other, making arbitration an attractive option because of its efficiency, structure, and neutrality. [5] Arbitration emerged as one mechanism for the U.S. to define each party’s rights and obligations.[6]
However, as time progressed, the focus began moving towards resolving specific financial and wartime liabilities through other means. From 1927-2021, the U.S. entered into seventy-five settlement agreements in the aftermath of war, during the Cold War, and in response to military incidents, expropriation claims, Holocaust-era compensation, and terrorism-related disputes.[7] These settlement agreements are often aimed at resolving large-scale or politically sensitive matters quickly and predictably.[8] In many ways, this shift made practical sense to address widespread harm even more efficiently than arbitration could.
Although these claims settlement agreements do not formally replace the arbitration treaties, it is worth noting that the U.S. has entered into such agreements with more countries than it has arbitration treaties.[9] For example, Cambodia’s only official treaty with the U.S. concerning dispute resolution is a property settlement claim.[10] Similarly, South Korea’s only dispute resolution treaty with the U.S. is a utilities claims settlement agreement.[11] As a result, for many states, claims settlement mechanisms have become the primary, and sometimes only, viable avenue for resolving disputes. The U.S. could continue to pursue arbitration treaties when handling international disputes because it gives both states an opportunity to design a unique arbitration procedure that is efficient, neutral, and responsive to their underlying dispute.
One of arbitration’s greatest strengths lies in its design. International arbitration stems from an arbitration clause or treaty that may govern the entire process. When proactively written, an arbitration agreement can determine which disputes are arbitrable, how arbitrators are selected,[12] the number of arbitrators on the arbitration panel,[13] what law applies, the language of the proceedings, and procedural rules.[14] This efficiency matters because international disputes are inherently expensive. Parties must often retain counsel who can travel and practice internationally, hire translators, interpreters, and expert witnesses to explain the nuances of foreign law or technical subject matter. These costs remain, regardless of whether the dispute is handled in a courtroom or in front of arbitrators. Yet, a well-drafted arbitration agreement can shorten the life cycle of the dispute by anticipating and streamlining many of the complexities that would otherwise slow down the resolution process and incur high costs.[15]
For example, the Arbitration Treaty Between the U.S. and Egypt, signed on August 27, 1929, requires both states to agree on setting up the tribunal, define its powers, state the exact legal questions, and explain the manner in which they wish to proceed before arbitration begins.[16] By doing so, both states will already have a clearer understanding of the legal issue and the procedural process ahead of time, so arbitration can be wholly dedicated to the underlying dispute. Disagreements regarding the number of arbitrators on the panel[17] or the allocation of the filing, administrative, and arbitrator’s fees are resolved long before the process begins. Many arbitration treaties from the early 1900s follow a similar structure to the U.S. and Egypt’s treaty and require the states to mutually agree on the arbitration process before they can take action.[18] Hence, a purposefully written arbitration agreement gives the states the freedom to efficiently design the type of dispute resolution process that will work best for their specific conflict.
Additionally, arbitration also provides a neutral ground for resolving the dispute.[19] International disputes frequently involve people from different legal traditions and cultures, which may affect their expectations of how they will be treated in a foreign court as opposed to their own State court. Both parties agree on the number of arbitrators and choose the specific arbitrators, effectively providing an opportunity to make sure all viewpoints are represented[20] and eliminate the worry about perceived biases.[21]
However, arbitration is not without its critics. Critics argue that it is neither as cost-effective nor as fast as advertised.[22] In reality, the upfront cost of filing for international arbitration is significantly more expensive.[23] For example, JAMS, a well-established arbitration service, requires a $2,000 international filing fee and a $2,000 counterclaim fee.[24] In addition, JAMS requires a 13% case management fee, alongside paying the arbitrator’s set hourly rates .[25] Arbitrators must be compensated and are usually paid in proportion to the amount of damages being sought.[26] These upfront fees can quickly amount to an unsettlingly high cost, making traditional litigation more attractive.
In addition to its cost, critics argue that arbitration creates its own unique challenges that can prolong the resolution process, like the choice of arbitrators.[27] Because the arbitration panel’s decision is generally final,[28] it is even more crucial that the states agree on the arbitrator’s expertise and neutrality. This will likely result in a long process of carefully proposing, rejecting, and reproposing potential arbitrators. In reality, the arbitration process may be extended when the parties cannot agree on these initial steps.
These critiques are accentuated when compared to the speed and cost of pursuing a claims settlement agreement. A claims settlement agreement establishes an even more streamlined way of compensating a large group of claimants and resolving politically charged disputes quickly. This is especially important when the harm is widespread, like following the aftermath of a war. Arbitration simply cannot compete when the harm is so large.
Nonetheless, the beauty of the law is that certain avenues of dispute resolution make more sense for specific instances. While claims settlements certainly have their strength for handling mass harms, arbitration is a powerful tool for individualized fact-finding. At its core, arbitration still preserves the spirit of adjudicating an issue based on its unique facts and the attorney’s capability of applying the law.
When cost and speed are a concern, there are numerous ways an arbitration treaty may strategically lower the cost, many of which have been discussed above. Many U.S. arbitration treaties have predetermined the venue for arbitration[29] and require the parties to sign an agreement that defines the scope of arbitration, including the procedure and exact legal questions that must be answered.[30] By establishing many of the procedural means well in advance, arbitration can largely focus on the merits of the dispute, which shortens the length of the dispute and ensuing costs.
Ultimately, international dispute resolution requires recognizing which process best fits the conflict at hand. The states’ historical reliance on arbitration treaties reflects this understanding that states benefit from a process that they can intentionally design to be efficient and neutral. Although claims settlement agreements have become more prevalent, particularly in response to mass harms and politically sensitive matters, they do not eliminate the value of arbitration. Arbitration is uniquely capable of preserving the individualized adjudication process sought after in a courtroom, while offering more choice for the parties. The parties can define the process before the dispute unfolds, anticipate the procedural obstacles, and create a forum that both sides trust. While critics are correct that arbitration can be costly and time-consuming in its own right, many of these concerns can be mitigated through thoughtful drafting and advanced agreement on important procedural elements.
Arbitration and claims settlements serve different, but equally valid, roles on an international legal level. Claims settlements can more efficiently address widespread harm, but arbitration offers a fact-specific mechanism for resolving disputes between states. For that reason, the U.S. should not abandon arbitration treaties and continue to employ them in future treaties.
[1] See S.I. Strong, Navigating the Borders Between International Commercial Arbitration and U.S. Federal Courts: A Jurisprudential GPS, 2012 J. Disp. Resol. 119, 119 (2012).
[2] Oehmke, Thomas H. Arbitrating International Claims–At Home and Abroad, 81 Am. Jur. Trials § 9 (2001). Privacy is otherwise unavailable in litigating an international dispute. When the legal dispute is sensitive in nature, the parties have an opportunity to protect the legal issue and, at times, their identities. While this broad confidentiality certainly raises legitimate concerns about transparency in terms of public interest, its power to protect diplomatic relationships and commercially sensitive information may, at times, outweigh the need to make everything publicly accessible.
[3] See e.g., Arbitration Convention, U.S.–Braz., Jan. 23, 1909, T.S. No. 562; Arbitration Convention, U.S.–Ecuador, Jan. 7, 1909, T.S. No. 549; Arbitration Convention, U.S.–Haiti, Jan. 7, 1909, T.S. No. 535; Arbitration Convention, U.S.–Peru, Dec. 5, 1908, T.S. No. 528; Arbitration Convention, U.S.–Uru., Jan. 9, 1909, T.S. No. 583; Arbitration Treaty, U.S.–Alb., Oct. 22, 1928, T.S. No. 770; Arbitration Treaty, U.S.–Austria, Aug. 16, 1928, T.S. No. 776; Arbitration Treaty, U.S.–Czechoslovakia, Aug. 16, 1928, T.S. No. 781; Arbitration Treaty, U.S.–Den., June 14, 1928, T.S. No. 784; Arbitration Treaty, U.S.–Fin., June 7, 1928, T.S. No. 768; Treaty of Arbitration, U.S.–Fr., Feb. 6, 1928, T.S. No. 785; Arbitration Treaty, U.S.–Ger., May 5, 1928, T.S. No. 774; Arbitration Treaty, U.S.–Hung., Jan. 26, 1929, T.S. No. 797; Arbitration Treaty, U.S.–Lith., Nov. 14, 1928, T.S. No. 809; Arbitration Treaty, U.S.–Pol., Aug. 16, 1928, T.S. No. 805; Arbitration Treaty, U.S.–Swed., Oct. 27, 1928, T.S. No. 783; Treaty of Arbitration, U.S.–Belg., Mar. 20, 1929, T.S. No. 823; Treaty of Arbitration, U.S.–Bulg., Jan. 21, 1929, T.S. No. 792; Treaty of Arbitration, U.S.–Egypt, Aug. 27, 1929, T.S. No. 850; Treaty of Arbitration, U.S.–Est., Aug. 27, 1929, T.S. No. 816; Treaty of Arbitration, U.S.–Ethiopia, Jan. 26, 1929, T.S. No. 799; Treaty of Arbitration, U.S.–Nor., Feb. 20, 1929, T.S. No. 788; Arbitration Treaty, U.S.–Port., Mar. 1, 1929, T.S. No. 803; Treaty of Arbitration, U.S.–Rom., Mar. 21, 1929, T.S. No. 794; Treaty of Arbitration, U.S.–Greece, June 19, 1930, T.S. No. 853; Treaty of Arbitration, U.S.–Ice., May 15, 1930, T.S. No. 828; Treaty of Arbitration, U.S.–Latvia, Jan. 14, 1930, T.S. No. 818; Treaty of Arbitration, U.S.–Lux., Apr. 6, 1929, T.S. No. 825; Treaty of Arbitration, U.S.–Neth., Jan. 13, 1930, T.S. No. 820; Treaty of Arbitration, U.S.–China, June 27, 1930, T.S. No. 857; Treaty of Arbitration and Conciliation, U.S.–Switz., Feb. 16, 1931, T.S. No. 844.
[4] Supra note3.
[5] See Oehmke supra note 2, § 3.
[6] Id.
[7] See e.g., Arrangement for the Disposal of Certain Pecuniary Claims Arising out of World War I, U.S.–U.K., May 19, 1927, T.S. No. 756; Convention for the Adjustment and Settlement of Certain Outstanding Claims, U.S.–Mex., Nov. 19, 1941, T.S. No. 980; Agreement Regarding Settlement for War Accounts and Claims, U.S.–Austria, June 21, 1947, T.I.A.S. No. 1920; Agreement Respecting Maritime Claims and Litigation, U.S.–Fr., Mar. 14, 1949, T.I.A.S. No. 1935; Agreement Relating to Procedure for Final Settlement of Claims of Italian Prisoners of War, U.S.–It., Feb. 14, 1948, T.I.A.S. No. 1948; Agreement Regarding the Settlement of Claims, U.S.–Hung., Mar. 6, 1973, 24 U.S.T. 522; T.I.A.S. No. 7569; Agreement on the Settlement of Certain Outstanding Claims and Financial Issues, U.S.–Czech., Jan. 29, 1982, T.I.A.S. No. 11264; Agreement Concerning the Foundation “Remembrance, Responsibility and the Future”, U.S.–Ger., July 17, 2000, T.I.A.S. No. 13104; Claims Settlement Agreement, U.S.–Libya, Aug. 14, 2008, T.I.A.S. No. 08-814, Claims Settlement Agreement, U.S.–Sudan, Oct. 30, 2020, T.I.A.S. No. 21-209; David J. Bederman, The United Nations Compensation Commission and the Tradition of International Claims Settlement, 27 N.Y.U. J. Int’l L. & Pol. 1, 3 (1994).
[9] See e.g., Agreement Concerning the Settlement of Certain Property Claims, Cambodia–U.S., Jan. 6, 1994, TIAS No. 12193 (Cambodia’s only dispute resolution treaty with the United States as of January 2025); Utilities Claims Settlement Agreement Between the Unified Command and Korea, S. Kor.–U.S., Dec. 18, 1958, 10 U.S.T. 41 (South Korea’s only dispute resolution treaty with the United States as of January 2025); Adherence by the United States to the Guidelines for the Work of Bilateral Committees to Resolve Certain Issues Involving the State of Kuwait and Other States, U.S.–Kuwait, Nov. 19, 2002, T.I.A.S. 02-1119 (Kuwait’s only dispute resolution treaty with the United States as of January 2025); Agreement Between the United States and the Republic of Iraq Concerning Claims Resulting from the Attack on the U.S.S. Stark, U.S.–Iraq, May 17, 1989, T.I.A.S. 12030 (Iraq’s one of two dispute resolution treaties with the United States as of January 2025); Claims Settlement Agreement Between the United States and the Republic of Iraq, U.S.–Iraq, Oct. 30, 2020, TIAS 11-522 (Iraq’s second dispute resolution treaty with the United States as of January 2025).
[10] See Agreement Concerning the Settlement of Certain Property Claims, Cambodia–U.S., Jan. 6, 1994, T.I.A.S. No. 12193.
[11] See Utilities Claims Settlement Agreement Between the Unified Command and Korea, S. Kor.–U.S., Dec. 18, 1958, 10 U.S.T. 41, T.I.A.S. 4168.
[12] See Oehmke supra note 2, § 5.
[13] Id. (an international arbitration treaty can determine which disputes require a three member arbitration panel versus which can be solved by just one arbitrator).
[14] Id. at § 3.
[15] Id. at § 4.
[16] See Treaty of Arbitration, U.S.–Egypt, Aug. 27, 1929, T.S. No. 850. Article 1.
[17] Supra note 9.
[18] See e.g., Treaty of Arbitration, U.S.–Ethiopia, Jan. 26, 1929, T.S. No. 799; Arbitration Treaty, U.S.–Ger., May 5, 1928, T.S. No. 774 (requiring the dispute to involve legal rights that are justiciable and diplomacy and mediation have failed before pursuing arbitration. If the states decide to arbitrate, they must sign an agreement that organizes the tribunal, defines its powers, clearly states the legal questions; and sets procedures. Senate approval is required for the U.S. and compliance with constitutional law is required by Germany); Treaty of Arbitration, U.S.–Nor., Feb. 20, 1929, T.S. No. 788 (requiring the dispute to involve international legal rights and diplomacy and resolution by the U.S. Norway conciliation commission have failed before pursuing arbitration. The states must sign an agreement that organizes the tribunal, defines its powers, clearly states the legal questions involved, and set procedures.).
[19] See John Fellas, A Fair and Efficient International Arbitration Process, 59 Disp. Resol. J. 78, 79-80 (2004).
[20] Id. at80.
[21] See e.g. Oehmke supra note 2, § 6. John Arrastia Jr. & Christi L. Underwood, Arbitration v. Litigation: You Control the Process v. the Process Controls You, 64-Jan. Disp. Resol. J., 31, 33 (2009) (noting the trend is to choose a panel of neutral arbitrators).
[22] See Linda Silberman, International Arbitration: Comments from a Critic, 13 Am. Rev. Int’l Arb. 9, 9 (2002).
[23] Id.
[24] JAMS, International Arbitration Fees, (last visited Feb. 26, 2026), https://www.jamsadr.com/international-arbitration-fees.
[25] See JAMS, International Arbitration Fees, (last visited Feb. 26, 2026), https://www.jamsadr.com/international-arbitration-fees; see also Aceris Law LLC, Total ICC Arbitration Costs, (last visited Feb. 26, 2026), https://www.acerislaw.com/icc-arbitration-costs/ (explaining the International Chamber of Commerce’s fee breakdown which includes a $5,000 filing fee, and an administrative and arbitrator fee that is proportional to the amount in dispute).
[26] See Linda Silberman, International Arbitration: Comments from a Critic, 13 Am. Rev. Int’l Arb. 9, 9 (2002).
[27] Id.
[28] See John Arrastia Jr. & Christi L. Underwood, Arbitration v. Litigation: You Control the Process v. the Process Controls You, 64-Jan. Disp. Resol. J., 31, 33 (2009) (“Final arbitration awards are binding, enforceable and almost impossible to challenge in court, since the grounds to appeal such awards are very limited and courts afford them great deference.”).
[29] See e.g., T.S. No. 799; Arbitration Treaty, U.S.–Ger., May 5, 1928, T.S. No. 774 (deciding arbitration disputes will be heard by the Permanent Court of Arbitration); Treaty of Arbitration, U.S.–Nor., Feb. 20, 1929, T.S. No. 788 (deciding arbitration disputes will be heard by the Permanent Court of Arbitration); Treaty of Arbitration, U.S.–Ethiopia, Jan. 26, 1929, T.S. No. 799 (deciding arbitration disputes will be heard by the Permanent Court of Arbitration); Treaty of Arbitration, U.S.–Nor., Feb. 20, 1929, T.S. No. 788 (deciding arbitration disputes will be heard by the Permanent Court of Arbitration).
[30] See e.g., Arbitration Treaty, U.S.–Ger., May 5, 1928, T.S. No. 774; Treaty of Arbitration, U.S.–Nor., Feb. 20, 1929, T.S. No. 788; Treaty of Arbitration, U.S.–Ethiopia, Jan. 26, 1929, T.S. No. 799; Treaty of Arbitration, U.S.–Nor., Feb. 20, 1929, T.S. No. 788.