Crisis in Calais: A Test of the European Court of Human Rights’ Prohibition on Degrading Treatment

https://www.flickr.com/photos/acampadabcnfoto/52439390146/in/photolist-2nTUZtE-2nTWfFA-2nTUZur-2rfVkTF-2nTTzEb-2nTUZu1-2rg2iak-2nTR2aw-2nTVUQq-2nTTzEg-2nTTzJj-2nTVUL2-2nTWfLL-2nTTzGL-2nTVUR2-2nTTzEw-2nTUZvt-2nTUZra-2nTUZvJ-2nTVURc-2nTR26D-2rfVkU7-2nTVULT-2nTWfGY-2nTWfLF-2nTVUQR-2nTR2bP-2nTR27f-2nTVURC-2nTUZwq-2nTWfMT-2nTR2cq-2nTUZt4-2nTWfJ1-2rg1Rzw-2nTTzKS-2nTVUNr-2nTWfJm-2nTUZsC-2nTR2d2-2nTR2cL-2nTR2cR-2nTWfJb-2rg2hSr-2nTQMuL-2nTUKZ5-2nTUKZa-2nTW2kx-2rg2i5k-2nTR2dx/
https://www.flickr.com/photos/acampadabcnfoto/52439390146/in/photolist-2nTUZtE-2nTWfFA-2nTUZur-2rfVkTF-2nTTzEb-2nTUZu1-2rg2iak-2nTR2aw-2nTVUQq-2nTTzEg-2nTTzJj-2nTVUL2-2nTWfLL-2nTTzGL-2nTVUR2-2nTTzEw-2nTUZvt-2nTUZra-2nTUZvJ-2nTVURc-2nTR26D-2rfVkU7-2nTVULT-2nTWfGY-2nTWfLF-2nTVUQR-2nTR2bP-2nTR27f-2nTVURC-2nTUZwq-2nTWfMT-2nTR2cq-2nTUZt4-2nTWfJ1-2rg1Rzw-2nTTzKS-2nTVUNr-2nTWfJm-2nTUZsC-2nTR2d2-2nTR2cL-2nTR2cR-2nTWfJb-2rg2hSr-2nTQMuL-2nTUKZ5-2nTUKZa-2nTW2kx-2rg2i5k-2nTR2dx/

Living conditions of migrants in Calais, France reveal a troubling paradox: the region is bound by the European Convention on Human Rights (“ECHR”), yet authorities continue to deprive migrants of the safe living conditions and dignity promised by its protections.1 Human rights investigations in Calais have recently exposed how unaccompanied children are subject to degrading conditions.2 France signed the ECHR in 1950 and ratified it in 1974; the treaty is enforced by the European Court of Human Rights (the “Court”).3 The international legal community should strengthen enforcement of ECHR Article 3 – prohibiting torture and inhuman or degrading treatment – to ensure that migrants in Calais access safe living conditions, sanitation, and protection from inhumane treatment. To structure this analysis, I will first define Article 3 and its relevant case law, then describe living conditions in Calais. Finally, I will examine how authorities have historically applied Article 3 and the potential for its use to protect migrants currently living in Calais. France has a “duty to protect” under Article 3 of the ECHR.4 Article 3 states that “[n]o one shall be subjected to torture or to inhuman or degrading treatment or punishment.”5 In deciding whether an action or series of actions in Calais violates Article 3, the Court has previously relied on living conditions in the camps and the treatment of particularly vulnerable groups.6 Beyond refraining from inhuman treatment, Article 3 imposes positive obligations on States; they must also take steps to prevent inhumane or degrading treatment occurring within their jurisdiction.7

Analysis of case law

In Khan v. France, a twelve-year-old unaccompanied Afghan minor lived for months in the makeshift camps of Calais, at the time known as the “Jungle” or “La Lande”.8 The minor lived in the camps during state-led evictions in unsafe and unsanitary conditions.9 A judicial order in February 2016 directed the Court to place the child in the care of the Direction de l’Enfance et de la Famille de Calais,but the authorities never complied with that decision.10 The Court found that the unsanitary and degrading conditions of the makeshift camp resulted in a violation of ECHR Article 3.11

The Khan Court ruled that the minor must receive €15,000 in non-pecuniary damages for their treatment in Calais.12 However, despite Khan, treatment of migrants in Calais remains degrading.13 Migrants remain in Calais because of their goal to travel to the U.K., and the presence of migrant communities will persist as long as they are prevented from attaining their goal.14 As a result, many migrants – including unaccompanied minors – will remain at risk of degrading treatment by police and the state.15 Given these ongoing conditions, the European Court of Human Rights must act decisively by urgently investigating all similar cases and reinforcing its rulings to ensure robust protection for Calais migrants facing.16

France and the U.K. blame each other for the conditions in Calais.17 Government statements treat Calais as a migration management issue rather than a human rights crisis .18 This approach highlights a conflict between human rights responsibilities and battles over restricted migration; however, Article 3 protections remain absolute.19 The sustained presence of migrants and ongoing rights violations in Calais highlight the fact that the situation cannot be addressed through migration management alone.20

Conclusion.

Looking forward, the living conditions in Calais are likely to remain a source of recurring human rights violations if there is no decisive action.21 The case of Khan v. France demonstrates both the applicability of Article 3 and the importance of action by the European Court of Human Rights. The responses to the crisis in Calais will serve as a test for translating international obligations into tangible protections.


1 ECtHR: France Fails to Fulfill its Duty to Protect an Unaccompanied Child Breached Article 3 of the Convention, Eur. Council on Refugees and Exiles (Mar. 1, 2019), https://ecre.org/ecthr-france-fails-to-fulfill-its-duty-to-protect-an-unaccompanied-child-breached-article-3-of-the-convention/].

2 Léa Pernot, France Failing Unaccompanied Migrant Children, Hum. Rights Watch (Oct. 24, 2025, at 1:00AM ET), https://www.hrw.org/news/2025/10/24/france-failing-unaccompanied-migrant-children].

3 Press Country Profile – France, Eur. Ct. H. R., 1 (Sept. 2025).

4 Article 3: Freedom from torture and inhuman or degrading treatment, Equal. and Hum. Rts. Comm’n. (June 3, 2021) https://www.equalityhumanrights.com/human-rights/human-rights-act/article-3-freedom-torture-and-inhuman-or-degrading-treatment].

5 Id.

6 ECtHR: France Fails to Fulfill its Duty to Protect an Unaccompanied Child Breached Article 3 of the Convention, supra note 1.

7 Khan v. France, App. No. 12267/16, ¶ 73 (May 28, 2019), https://hudoc.echr.coe.int/eng?i=001-191587].

8 Id at ¶¶ 49-52

9 Eléonore Aubry, Protection of Minors in Calais, 3 Eur. Hum. Rts. L. Rev. 316-18 (2019).

10Id.

11Id.

12 Khan v. France, App. No. 12267/16, ¶ 101 (May 28, 2019), https://hudoc.echr.coe.int/eng?i=001-191587].

13 Annalisa Lendaro, Justice in the Jungle: Litigation and Judicial Violence in Calais Refugee Camps at the French–UK Border, 69(6) Am. Behav. Scientist. 771-92 (2025).

14 Id.

15 France responsible for grave and systematic violations of rights of unaccompanied migrant children, UN committee finds, U.N. Hum. Rts. Off. of the High Commissioner (Oct. 16, 2025). https://www.ohchr.org/en/press-releases/2025/10/france-responsible-grave-and-systematic-violations-rights-unaccompanied].

16 Id.

17   Sudip Kar-Gupta, Macron says record illegal Channel crossings point to Brexit failure, Reuters (July 10, 2025, at 13:36 MT), https://www.reuters.com/world/uk/macron-says-record-illegal-channel-crossings-point-brexit-failure-2025-07-10/#:~:text=Summary,the%20problem%20has%20become%20Brexit.%22 ].

18 France: Minister Refutes Cruelty of Calais Evictions, “Indirect” Expulsions of Afghans Feared, Channel Crossings and Rescues Continue, Eur. Council on Refugees and Exiles (Oct. 22, 2021). https://ecre.org/france-minister-refutes-cruelty-of-calais-evictions-indirect-expulsions-of-afghans-feared-channel-crossings-and-rescues-continue/ ].

19 Article 3: Freedom from torture and inhuman or degrading treatment, Supra note 4.

20 France: Minister Refutes Cruelty of Calais Evictions, “Indirect” Expulsions of Afghans Feared, Channel Crossings and Rescues Continue, supra note 18.

21 Lendaro, supra note 13.